Bill C2

The Right Honourable Mark Carney, P.C., M.P.

Prime Minister of Canada


This letter was submitted to the Canadian Parlement, PM, and several MPs September 2025, prior to Bill C2's third reading.

Hill Office
House of Commons
Ottawa, Ontario,
Canada
K1A 0A6
mark.carney@parl.gc.ca


Dear Prime Minister,

I am writing to you regarding Bill C-2 (The Strong Boarders Act), which sets for me a terrifying precedent. It's proposed as technical measures and safeguards to strengthen our borders, yet it erodes the spirit of our Charter Of Rights and Freedoms, and hard-wires into our system yet another layer of circular dependency, ultimately tightening social stratification in Canada.

I'd like to begin by pointing out that the following words are mine, and while I appreciate the potential benefit of LLMs and related technologies I feel it important given the context of this letter to bear my soul, rather than the well constructed yet ultimately empty words produced by a machine.

I live differently than most Canadians. I live off-grid, by choice and necessity. Additionally I've held a PWGSC security clearance for over a decade during the course of my previous employment. That difference, under a system of suspicion without proper judicial oversight, could easily be misread as dangerous. The implied trust that authorities will be impartial, is mathematically unrealistic. No human system can fully escape bias and once bias is given teeth through law, it can devastate innocent lives.

I say this with respect for the RCMP as an institution, but also with realism: to assume it's ranks contain no bad actors is to ignore fact. What separates Canada from countries where police corruption is rampant is largely culture and opportunity, it is folly to believe in it's immunity. If Bill C-2 expands authority without equally expanding accountability, we're betting the integrity of our society on the assumption that institutions will always operate with perfect honesty. The nature of human limits are at odds with that assumption; it is a gamble no democracy should make.

This is not abstract. Technologies exist that can approach reading intent, even thought. Imperfect, but close enough to justify suspicion in the wrong hands. For a law-abiding citizen, this very idea should be more terrifying than crime itself. Crime is visible and punishable; state overreach, once normalized, becomes the monster.

Canada's legal and regulatory framework now spans tens of thousands of statutes, regulations and restrictions - a number that has grown alarmingly over the decades. Given this vast catalogue, virtually any citizen's normal conduct can be framed as suspicious when examined closely enough. In statistics, large data sets always contain anomalies; if authorities are permitted endless attempts to sift though them, they are all but guaranteed to find patterns that appear incriminating, even when they arise purely by chance. This risks confirmation bias: once suspicion is formed, the system ensures that suspicion will eventually be 'confirmed', not because of actual wrongdoing, but because the body of law is so overwhelmingly broad. Sections 14 & 15 of Bill C-2 risk enshrining this principal, eroding the presumption of innocence in favour of perpetual suspicion while handing authorities tools that no free society should normalize. If we continue to entrench these dependencies, we risk trading cultural well being, personal agency, independence, functional freedom of expression, and even mental stability for only the illusion of safety.

As a software developer, I take pride in building secure systems that protect the trust of the people who use them. Bill C-2.15 presents a chilling prospect: that I, or others in my position, could be compelled to undermine the very security we are committed to uphold - not because of wrongdoing, but in service of secretive surveillance mandates. This would effectively criminalize honourable, responsible behaviour, and make good-faith work a potential liability. It places professionals in a very real moral problem: either betray the trust of those we serve, or risk being treated as a suspect ourselves. This does not strengthen Canada's security; it corrodes it, by eroding the integrity of those who wish to contribute constructively.

To illustrate, we need only turn to recent history. Powers created for the worst cases are almost always expanded. Scope creep is the rule, not the exception. Inevitably, such laws are turned inward, weaponized against the very society they claim to protect: The War Measures Act, introduced as temporary, became a blueprint for sweeping state control. The U.S. Patriot Act, sold as an emergency measure, metastasized into a permanent surveillance system. Here in Canada the questionably broad application of the Emergencies Act upended lives of protesters exercising their chartered right to freedom of expression. In East Germany, the Stasi didn't need perfect accuracy, suspicion alone was enough to ruin lives. History doesn't whisper here it shouts... Are we listening?

Currently a chilling trend is sweeping western world: Age verification systems in the UK and Australia, and the EU's proposed Chat Control Bill. As a person well versed in the applicable technology, I am stunned at the moves made by these respected institutions. I cannot ignore my intuition that these regulations are individual snowflakes of the same blizzard. While I'm certain that these institutions have good reason to seek protection against various threats - both perceived and real - potentially exacerbated by foreign and home-grown actors leveraging AI-powered bot farms - spraying misinformation, division, and hate; I can assure you there are other ways to mitigate these concerns without undermining the fundamental privacy rights of innocent citizens. Dwindling trust in institutions is exacerbated by negative elements, but the cited reasons for proposing these bills risk being misleading in their technical premise, and therefore work against the very goals they claim to serve. Plainly said: I believe the technical assumptions of these bills, including our own C-2.14, are dangerous; regardless of intent.

Furthermore, we have an subtle yet powerful example in the recent events of our southern neighbour. In the United States, powers introduced under the Patriot Act were originally justified as necessary to combat terrorism. Over time, successive administrations have expanded their use far beyond that scope, currently to the point to labelling dissenting groups as potential terrorist organizations. This re-framing allows broad investigative and surveillance powers to be directed at citizens engaged in protest or political opposition, weaponizing national security law against dissent. It is a striking reminder that the spirit of a law can be quietly abandoned once authorities are permitted to redefine who qualifies as a "threat". To quote George Orwell: "If liberty means anything at all, it means the right [and ability] to tell people what they do not want to hear."

Is freedom even possible when the state presumes to know your mind before you act or even speak? Safety that costs our liberty, and by extension our independence, is merely a slower type of danger; danger none the less. I fully accept that these regulations may indeed be advanced with the greater good in mind, and that your government may act in good faith. What about the governments that follow you, can you affirm that this machinery will not be abused when wielded by those who we do not yet know?

Unless we are able to speak openly, express ourselves, and share ideas effectively; not just in law, but in spirit, the very foundation that makes democracy possible is undermined. It isn't enough merely stating we have freedom of expression - that assertion needs willing defenders acting in good faith to maintain it. Our rights, and the functional democracy they support cannot be taken for granted. Disrespected, our Charter of Rights and Freedoms' is vulnerable to the aforementioned scope creep, inexorably set upon through forces rooted in fear and protectionism.

I urge you not only to oppose this bill technically and in spirit, but to recognize the broader trajectory it signals. A democracy cannot thrive when its citizens are quietly sorted, monitored, and pressured into compliance by invisible systems of law and technology. Do not permit the slow suffocation of a free society, in the name of it's security.

Respectfully,

Tyler Anderson

Comments on the article?
Visit the Group Chat Everyone is welcome!
If you're curious, check out XMPP.org for info and software.